
An eagle-eyed reader directed us to read a blog post by right-wing Tory MP Douglas Carswell earlier this week. The article claimed that the Fabian Society had copied the design for a poster/leaflet from the cover of the ‘The Plan’, the “best selling book I wrote with Daniel Hannan”.
Both designs were helpfully placed side by side, and they do indeed look very similar. No more proof is needed for the Tory MP, this “takes this ‘imitation-is-flattery’ to extremes” claimed Carswell.
He even used the opportunity to draw other conclusions:
“Perhaps the left will do more than copy our cover as well? What more proof do you need? The British left has run out of ideas.”
The problem for Carswell is that as co-author of The Plan, he was in a very good position to find out the truth of these claims before he published them. One call to his publisher and he’d have discovered, as we did when we contacted the Fabian Society, that the image in question is a ’stock image’ freely available to any designer to use.
That news may come as a shock for the window-lickers who left comments on the blog such as “sue the b*st*rds!” and “that’s a clear breach of copyright. The designer of the book’s cover should sue”. Which is a shame because their embarrassment could have been avoided if Carswell had answered the very first comment: “Do you and/or Daniel Hannan own the copyright on the image?”
The answer of course is “no”.
Now the truth has been revealed, it turns out that there are grounds for legal action – not by Carswell and chums, but by the designer of the Fabian Society artwork for libel and defamation. It’s a serious matter falsely claiming that a designer copied his work from the opposition. Is Carswell man enough to apologise though?
UPDATE: Daniel Hannan MEP, co-author of ‘The Plan’, conspicuously didn’t repeat the claim that the Fabian Society copied the image in his Daily Telegraph blog yesterday.
Other news from Labour Matters
Discussion
View Comments for “Conservative MP should apologise after copy claims are exposed as false”